Medical Malpractice in Organ Transplant Surgery
Medical malpractice in healthcare has been widely studied, but when it comes to organ transplants, research is surprisingly limited. A recent study, published in Frontiers, set out to fill this critical gap, shedding light on the risks and legal complexities surrounding these life-saving procedures.
Researchers looked at a selection of cases involving malpractice from 1988 through 2023 involving organ transplants. Each of the cases was classified into one of six malpractice categories:
- Surgical Errors (31.8%) These included mistakes during and after surgery, such as incorrect tube insertion, failure to clamp arteries, and surgical instruments that mistakenly stayed inside the body.
- Medication & Treatment Errors (26.1%) These mostly involved incorrect medication use, leading to transplant rejection or adverse reactions.
- Quality of Care & Monitoring (13.6%) This included inadequate post-transplant monitoring, delays in critical care, and insurance-related denials.
- Organ Quality & Donor Issues (11.4%) This involved transplants from donors with undisclosed risks (e.g., history of drug use, underlying health conditions).
- Misdiagnosis & Delayed Treatment (9.1%) This included failure to monitor patients properly, misdiagnosed complications, and delays in necessary care.
- Patient Rights & Informed Consent (6.8%) Some patients claimed they were not properly informed about the risks of their transplant.
Among the cases reviewed, a heart transplant patient died after an error during surgery, resulting in the largest settlement of $19.9 million. A kidney transplant recipient was given an organ from a donor with an unknown infection, leading to serious complications. A liver transplant patient developed hepatitis B due to undisclosed donor risks. A patient lost a kidney when it was accidentally discarded.
The most common organ involved was a kidney (46.8% of cases). The most frequent allegations were surgical errors and complications, and medication and treatment mistakes.
If you need an attorney who takes on medical malpractice cases against big hospitals, know that Tom Duffy has obtained recoveries and settlements from most of the large teaching hospitals and universities in the Philadelphia area. Please contact us to see if he can help with medical malpractice case.